01
Why two quotes for the same dent can be so different
- Labour rates vary a lot by area and by shop. A main-dealer bodyshop in a city and an independent in a market town can be far apart before anyone has looked at the car.
- Repair or replace: one shop plans to pull and fill a wing, another prices a new wing. Both are valid, but they're different jobs.
- Parts: genuine, aftermarket or used. Unless you say which you want, each shop will assume something different.
- Paint: a proper match often means blending into the panels next door, which adds hours. A cheaper quote may simply have left that out.
- Hidden damage: a quote from photos is an estimate. Once the bumper's off there may be broken brackets or a bent slam panel underneath.
- Modern cars: wheel alignment and ADAS calibration after a front or rear repair are real costs. A quote that skips them isn't cheaper, it's incomplete.
02
Describe the damage so shops can price it
The better the brief, the closer the estimate will be to the final bill. Send the same brief to every shop so the quotes line up.
- Photos: the whole car from the damaged corner, each damaged panel straight on, a close-up of every dent, crack or scratch, and the underside or inside the boot and bonnet if anything looks pushed in.
- The car: make, model, year and trim, plus the paint code from the sticker in the door jamb or under the bonnet.
- What happened: a low-speed car-park scrape and a 30 mph shunt look similar in a photo and aren't.
- What you want: a like-new finish, a tidy repair, or simply roadworthy and legal. Say so.
- Parts: whether you want genuine, aftermarket or used, and whether you've already got any.
- Timescale: when you can drop the car off and when you need it back.
03
What a proper quote should include
- Itemised parts with whether each is genuine, aftermarket or used, and part numbers where possible.
- Labour hours and the hourly rate, not just a total.
- Paint and materials, and whether blending adjacent panels is included.
- Wheel alignment and ADAS calibration where the car needs them, or a note that they're excluded.
- VAT, stated clearly, and how long the quote is valid for.
- A warranty on the paint and the workmanship, in writing.
- What happens if hidden damage turns up: how they'll tell you, and that nothing extra is done without your say-so.
04
How to compare quotes fairly
Put the quotes next to each other and compare line by line, not total against total. If one shop is much cheaper, find the line that explains it: a repaired panel instead of a new one, no blending, aftermarket parts, no calibration. Then decide whether that's a saving you're happy with.
- Ask the outlier why. A good shop will explain its price; a vague answer tells you something too.
- Read reviews from people who've had the same kind of work done, and ask to see finished examples.
- Visit if you can. A shop with a proper paint booth, a jig for structural work and a tidy floor is telling you how it works.
- For structural repairs, ask whether the shop works to BS 10125, the British standard for vehicle body repair.
- Check how they'll keep you posted. Photos part-way through are normal now and worth asking for.
05
Agree it before the work starts
Get the final price, the exact scope, the parts choice, the timescale, any deposit and the payment terms in writing. Under the Consumer Rights Act 2015 the work has to be carried out with reasonable care and skill, and a written agreement makes that far easier to hold a shop to if anything goes wrong.
Photograph the car and note the mileage when you drop it off, and agree how extras will be handled: a message with a photo and a price, and nothing done until you've said yes.
06
If it's an insurance claim
Your insurer will usually offer an approved repairer. Most policies also let you use a repairer of your own choice, although some add an excess or withdraw the courtesy car when you do, so check the policy wording before you decide. Whichever way you go, the same rules apply: a clear brief, an itemised quote and the extras agreed in writing.
